DCBA Brief Online - Journal of the DuPage County Bar Association

DCBA Home Page
Brief Home Page

Brief Display Rates

Article Index

Index Search

Articles for
April 2007

President's Message

Editor's Message

Legal Features

State of the Courthouse Address

THE GRIEF (pdf file)

A Military Law Primer: How the Uniform Code of Military Justice is a Model for the Treatment of Defendants in Criminal Cases

What Happened To Protecting The Children? An Argument Against Parental Immunity For Foster Parents

© 1996 - 2007
DuPage County
Bar Association
All Rights Reserved.

DCBA Brief's President's Message
April 2007

REAL ESTATE LAWYERS UNITE

Real estate and other transactional attorneys are the "silent majority" of our association. We know you’re out there even when we don’t often hear from you. Even those real estate lawyers who do grace the Judicial Center escalator (whether working or not) rarely speak out. It is time for the silent majority to be heard. "We" real estate lawyers cannot fiddle away in our own transactional world while the real estate law business as we know it is about to burn. Buy a piece of real estate west of the Mississippi or now even south of I-88 if you want to know what I mean. In many, if not most, of those real estate transactions, the only lawyers involved are the ones who own or manage the escrow company. It’s time to sound the horn, circle the wagons or such other cliché. The battle front for real estate lawyers is now at our doorstep.

IRELA Leads the Charge

The Illinois Real Estate Lawyers Association (IRELA) is at the forefront of the battle lines. For example, litigation is now pending in the Circuit Court of McHenry County. IRELA has filed suit against One World Title Corp. asserting that the title company is engaged in the unauthorized practice of law (UPL). Our member and ISBA Third Vice President, John G. O’Brien, is the plaintiff in the litigation, along with IRELA. Joseph Fortunato, long standing DCBA member and our former Real Estate Law Chairperson, is an expert witness for IRELA.

At issue in the IRELA litigation is a document titled "Sellers Binding Agreement for the Purchase of Title Insurance." The Defendant real estate broker submitted this "Binding Agreement" at the time the real estate sellers executed a listing agreement. The agreement purports to restrict the sellers’ right to subsequently obtain title insurance from anyone other than "One World Title." Although the sellers are given a three-day right of cancellation, IRELA has convincing evidence that a seller of real estate does not even consult with an attorney until there is a contractual offer which is long after the three-day right of recision has expired. In the event the seller fails to consummate the Agreement, One World files suit for its lost revenue. One World Title has previously filed suit against an attorney (One World Title Corp. v. Bolger) asserting that the attorney intentionally interfered with its contractual right to perform title services because the attorney used a title company of her own choosing.

IRELA asserts in the pending litigation that it is the role of the attorney to discern which title company is best suited for the client to clear title exceptions. IRELA has a line of real estate practitioners who have testified at deposition and who will testify at trial that the choice of a title company is dependent upon multiple factors and it is through the experience of a knowledgeable real estate attorney that the ultimate decision should be made on behalf of the client. Factors that real estate lawyers use in determining the appropriate title company include the insurers underwriting capability, claims history, expertise in potential survey issues, previous underwriting experience for the same property, financial stability, experience of the legal department, and competency in resolving title issues and claims.

One World Title defends with arguments to the effect that the choice of a title company does not import "legal advice" and further asserts that when it uses a contract with its own customers, the "pro se exception to the unauthorized practice of law applies."

Let’s Pay Attention

We all need to pay attention to the outcome of the IRELA litigation and other inroads to our practice areas. Support the IRELA litigation as the DCBA has chosen to do so. Attend DCBA Real Estate Law Committee meetings and become a leader. Pound your shoe on the table. Demand action from the ISBA UPL Committee, CBA, KCBA and our own DCBA. Be the "silent majority" no more. Your livelihood is at issue. Finally, to all lawyers who don’t do real estate closings, please consider what will become of all the lawyers who do, if their ability to support their families dissipates. Your "space" may get crowded. You’re in this too!

I 2 F …IT’S FREE!

Recently, Chris Kachiroubas, Dewey Hartman and the staff of the Circuit Court Clerk of DuPage County unveiled its new free e-filing system. By the time you read this President’s Page, you should be able to access the Clerk’s program at "I2file.net." Payments for new filings, appearance fees, etc., are accepted via credit card (with a small service fee). All motions and other non-fee filings are FREE. The Clerk’s system does not yet effectuate service to your opponent which may become a future added feature. Also, any document filed electronically by 4:30 p.m. is deemed filed on that day, regardless of when the Clerk’s office subsequently opens and posts your document. Any document which you file after 4:30 p.m. is deemed filed on the next Court business day.

WORTH REPEATING

Based upon popular demand, the following portion of my last President’s Page has been requested again, so here it is:

Sshhh! Don’t tell anyone else. This is between just you and me. Have you ever seen Judge Abraham pull up your case file on his computer and show you the content of a prior Court Order or some document you filed? Haven’t you said, "Damn ….. I’d sure like to do that." Because YOU are a loyal DCBA member and read my President’s Page, here’s how you can do the same thing from the privacy of your own office or home.

Step 1 – Go to www.dupagecase.org/ (Circuit Clerk Kachiroubas restricted information system)

Step 2 – Click on the words "submit request here"

Step 3 – When the web browser certificate screen pops up, type in your name and email address. Click on "submit."

Step 4 – The system will provide you with a certificate request number. Write it down.

Step 5 – Send an email to Dewey Hartman, administrator. His email address is dhartman@dupageco.org. Tell him that you are a DCBA member and that President Gaffney requests that he approve your request for a certificate. Alternatively, call Dewey’s office at (630) 407-8581 and communicate verbally the same information. Don’t forget to give Dewey your certificate request number which you have written down. Also contact Mary Louise Heaton, (630) 407-8579; email mary.heaton@ dupageco.org.

Step 6 – Obtain your password number with your certificate approval.

Step 7 – You’re in. Send me an email describing how you like the system and what you’re using it for. If it’s not working, call Fred Spitizzeri.

Glenn R. Gaffney is the principal of Gaffney & Gaffney aka Gaffney and Son in Glendale Heights, concentrating his practice on employment law litigation. He received a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration and Marketing from the University of Illinois Champaign/Urbana and a J.D., cum laude, from Southern Illinois University School of Law.

 Top of Page